Saturday, April 3, 2010
So What is Next?
Yes, they celebrate Christmas in prisons. Some have a not too bad family Christmas, but to many it is just another day. So what happens after 18 years inside? Derik has had that and it is now more than half his life spent behind those bars. He does not have regular family type Christmases. His father has not been allowed to see him for over 4 years now.
As I said in previous posts, he sits in prison wrongfully convicted of two counts of first degree murder. Because he will not confess to a crime he did not commit, he stays there. After 2 years of fighting with the system, he was finally moved to William Head Prison where he successfully completed his first year apprenticeship training in carpentry. He has a certificate in house framing, a first aid ticket, training in building foundations, framing walls, installing floors, constructing roof trusses, finishing the roof and putting in doors and windows properly. He has done insulation, siding, basic plumbing along with that. He is gaining some hours in the trade working with the onsite carpenter. He also is getting skidsteer loader esperience.
He will be gaining very few hours if he stays at William Head. So he heard about a large construction project starting at another prison. There he would get the hours he needs to complete his first year of apprenticeship. So, upon completion of his course and getting his grades, he applied to transfer out to the other prison.
Surprise!! Well, not really. As you have seen in previous postings, transfers for him have been particularly difficult. This one is no different. His Internal Parole Officer, IPO, has informed him that she will not support him for a transfer. She will not support him for family visits with his sister. She will not support him for escorted passes to the college to continue learning. She refused to even speak to him for at least 2 years. She has refused to do the paperwork that is her job. So, there he still sits. Again the system failed!
I tried to call her to get her point of view on this and perhaps a reason for her not to support him. She hung up on me. She told me that she does not speak to parents of prisoners. Why she won't use such a valuable resource to reach him I don't understand. What is she teaching him? That his views on the abusiveness of authority figures are well founded. Teaching him that if he bends over to be fucked, he might get something. Teaching him that women who work in prisons hate men. Teaching him that the system needs him for continuation of the jobs created by his incarceration.
You would think that a system basing its mandate on rehabilitation would be trying to educate, socialize and generally prepare men for re-entry into society. Instead, the system relies on continued incarceration, so any attempt at improving a prisoner's ability to earn a living, get along with people, control his anger, or anything else that might help him succeed is quashed. This young man, having gone from high school to prison, has never lived on his own. Should he not be offered as much education and life skills as possible? Apparently not, the system is concerned about job security and keeps him locked in.
Please write to the Deputy Commissioner of Corrections Canada, Ms. Anne Kelly, to offer your opinion on this.
Regional Headquarters - Pacific
32560 Simon Avenue
PO Box 4500
2nd Floor
Abbotsford, British Columbia
V2T 5L7
Phone: (604) 870-2500
Fax: (604) 870-2430
Deputy Commissioner: Anne Kelly
Tel.: (604) 870-2501
Fax: (604) 870-2430
Contact me:
Skype: coach_elouise
email: lordelouise@gmail.com
By the way, the other boy convicted at the same trial made up a confession and has been out on parole for 8 years now. He works as a cleaner at a local hospital.
Friday, February 26, 2010
When in Prison, Don't be Honest!
This video made me laugh a lot!. However. It is nothing like life in Prison. Derik has been in prison now for 18 years. What for? for knowing the wrong person. Not that there was anything wrong with his friend other than a psychosis which he was getting treatment for. But when his friend's mother and grandmother were murdered, his friend was the type of person who falls under suspicion right away. Not because he was a violent person, but because he was super polite and had an attitude of superiority.
The long and the short of it is that since Derik and two friends were together for at least part of the evening in question, they were targeted as likely suspects and subsequently convicted of the crime with no physical evidence to back up the verdict.
I had an eye-opening experience with police investigations gone wrong. I know who commissioned the killings, but I cannot prove it. The hitman is in China. There is no extradition treaty with Chine, so as soon as an investigation heads that way it is usually dropped. I have seen the police use lies, force, coersion, and many other not so legal methods to get witnesses to change their testimony. I did not believe one could be convicted on hearsay evidence alone. But now I know better. It happens from time to time. It happened to Derik.

He was sentenced to life 10, along with another boy about the same age. The other boy fell for the coersion in prison. Guards, Parole officers, other officers, all tell prisoners that they have to confess to get out of prison. Legally, they do not have to do that. Derik went against the crowd. He said he would refuse to confess to a crime he did not commit. Especially, he would not confess to such a terrible one. Lots of prisoners say they did not do it, but they stay in prison for much longer times because of that denial. The other boy admitted and confessed to the crime. We do not know what he said to the prison staff, but by the time the 10 years was up, he was out of prison and on parole for the rest of his life. Derik still refuses to confess to this terrible crime. So he is still in prison.
The system has tried many ways to coerce him into making a false confession. Just to get out of prison. He still maintains his innocence and refuses to make that lie. So there he sits.
It is not like he has done nothing while in there. He has worked hard to improve himself. Since he was not allowed to complete high school, he obtained his equivalency certificate. He took the pilot course in peer counselling in prison. He became a peer counsellor for the other prisoners, helping them with sucidal tendencies, depression, marital issues, parenting issues and whatever else he could help them work through. He is well respected for that job. He has done every program the parole board wanted him to do except the ones where he has to confess. He has had passes outside of the prison. One for his grandmother's funeral, several for LINC meetings. LINC is lifers in the community who counsel others who have been in prison for a long time on how to survive on the outside.
He has tried to get passes for education, but since the class times are long and no guards want to sit on the classes, he was not able to get those. About 2 years ago he transferred to another prison to obtain a carpentry course. The first year of an appenticeship program in building construction. At first, the staff at this new place would not allow him into the course although he transferred there just to take that course. Finally, by going above the staff and appealing to th administration, he got the course. He has completed that successfully and is now certified as a framer for construciton.
But. Now the worst blow of all. With this training and having obtained the best overall score in the course, he is trying to get a transfer to another prison where they are rebuilding the entire place. They want prisoner workers to do the work. His parole officer will not support him for that as she said that she wants him to stay there for at least another two years just to do time. So, here we go again. This time he will once again have to go to administration for results. Why can they not help guys get out to support themselves?
Taxpayers are blind to the fact that it costs in the neighbourhood of $100 000.00 to keep a man in prison for one year. More if health issues are present. these guys should be out, earning their own keep. Paying taxes like the rest of us. Learning how to live with other people without resorting to crime. Some, in fact, many, would never go back to crime if they had job skills.
Now, Derik has served nearly twice what the other boy served. He will not confess because he is innocent. I used to tell my kids to always be honest. Now I suspect that is a mistake. No one else is honest.
Canadian injustice
Elouise
skype: coach_elouise
email: rascal60@shaw.ca
Tuesday, February 9, 2010
Who cares for the prisoners?
Well the same things keep happening over and over again. To my followers who say they are tired of hearing about Derik and the things he has to go through, I say listen and learn. There are many things in Canada's prison system that need changing.
Derik has finally completed the first year carpentry training that he transferred to William Head prison to take. It took 8 months to get into the program because his Internal Parole Officer had decided that 16 years was not enough punishment for him. She said he could not get anything from her at all. And to think that all he wanted to do was to get a trade in order to perhaps support a family should he ever get out of that terrible place.
Canadian Correctional Services calls the time spent in those jails rehabilitation time. Not much actual rehabilitation takes place from the service end of things. Rehabilitation occurs when the prisoners themselves decide they want another attempt at a real life. See a few of my earlier posts for more on this topic.
Derik has been trying to do several things while in those institutions. He has been trying to prove his innocence of the crime. So far, nothing has come from that, but the UBC Law School students are still working on it.
He has been trying to stay away from the very large drug culture inside those institutions. So far, he has been successful at that. He has even been able to help a couple of others stop the horrible circle of getting high, scoring another hit and getting high. It is a tough road. Drugs are much more easily obtainable inside than on the street. They are also a lot cheaper. The institutions don't appear to be able to stop the inflow. They only check visitors, not staff. Way more comes in through staff than through visitors. Even the prisons on lockdown don't have a shortage of drugs with no visitors coming in at all.
He has been trying to obtain some sort of training that he can use to find work if he is ever released. To that end, it took him nearly 5 years to get some cooperation from the officials in charge to get his first year apprenticeship for carpentry. Now he is employable. He has a Framer's ticket, a forklift ticket, and experience with concrete foundations. He has installed and removed windows and doors and done some roofing.
He has been trying to obtain escorted passes outside of the institution. He wants to visit his neice and nephew in their own home, not in a prison. He wants to get a job and earn some money so he can get out of prison and have a place to go. He wants to get passes to take more courses towards his carpentry. Now that he has finally been able to obtain some education towards that end, his Internal Parole Officer, who did not support him for the course, is refusing to support him for any sort of passes, work release, education, or transfer to another institution for at least another 2 years.
Why? 19 years is still not long enough punishment. His crime? He refuses to admit guilt and confess to something that he did not do. He was not there. He has support from other guards, other parole officers, other staff, but without the ok of this particular bitch, he cannot do anything or go anywhere. His sentence was for 10 years until parole eligibility. Many people outside the system think that means he would serve 10 years and be out. Boy are they wrong!! That is not how it works for those who disagree with something. Derik will not confess to something he is innocent of, so he remains.
Please help by writing to the Minister of Public Safety in our federal government to urge prison reform. Training and release is their mandate, but it is not what they are doing.
Minister of Public Safety,
Parliament Buildings,
Ottawa, Ontario,
Canada K1A 0P9
For more of Derik's story, check out http://www.canadianinjustice.com
or contact me
Elouise
skype: coach_elouise
email: lordelouise@gmail.com
Friday, August 7, 2009
Again
http://closer-look.blogspot.com/2007/01/derik-lords-long-wait-jan.html
It is extremely hard in Canada to get a wrongful convicton overturned. We may never be able to do that.
My biggest issue with the system of incarceration we have here is the lack of parole availability. Our Parole Board states over and over that he will not see the outside of a prison without confessing to the crime. That volates the Criminal Code of Canada, is against the National Parole Board's own policies, flies in the face of the agreements Canada has signed with other countries under the United Nations umbrella, and is just not fair.
Derik, because he has family and friends who support him, has been able to stay away from the bad things that happen in our prisons on a regular basis. For example, he has not started using drugs, which are so readily available inside our prisons. Other prisoners have told me drugs are not only more avalable, they are cheaper than on the street. Drugs are the biggest problem inside our prisons. Management tries many things to solve the issue, but the roadblocks set up by the Guard's Union keep the measures from being more effective. Sure searching visitors catches some of the drugs being brought in, but not searching the gym bags and other containers brought in by guards gives a large avenue of importation that is not being closed off.
The only way to stop that door is to remove guards from the front entrances and replace them with a different security force such as the Commissionaires. That way, union members are not searching other union members. It would close a very large portal for getting contraband into the prisons.
The lack of family support becomes more apparent when we attend social events in the prisons. I have been approached by many prisoners who have not seen any family members or friends since being incarcerated. There are many reasons for this, but from what I have seen, visiting is not encouraged by the system. Although they give mouth to a great policy and openness for visiting, in actual practice, it does not happen easily. My husband has not seen his son for nearly 3 years now because they do not like his words. He writes letters to upper anagement noting obvious, glaring errors in the functioning of the visitng process. Because he embarrasses them, he is not allowed to visit. Derik has even been told to shut his father up and he might get parole! What a farce!
I can't help everyone, but I have supported some men who finally were able to gain parole. All except one have stayed out because they had someone to talk to outside of the prison environment. Someone who could give advice, support ( not with money) and just be friendly. These men are doing fine now. workng, supporting themselves and in some cases, their families, participating in outreach activties in the prisons, and more. Many more helpful people are needed in order to reduce Canada's growing prison population. Our Federal Government and its policies make it a very hard place to be.
http://www.canadianinjustice.com
Please write our Prime Minister
Stephen HARPER
Office of the Prime Minister of Canada,
Parliament Buildings,
Ottawa,
Ontario,
Canada
Coach Elouise
604-794-3218
Skype coach_elouise
Email: lordelouise@gmail.com
rascal60@shaw.ca
http://coachelouise.com
Monday, June 29, 2009
The cost of wrongful convictions
WRONGFUL CONVICTIONS
Some of the Canadians who have been exonerated after being wrongfully convicted
STEVEN TRUSCOTT
Truscott, 14 at the time, was charged with the rape and killing of 12-year-old Lynne Harper in 1959. He was sentenced to hang, but instead spent 10 years in prison. In 2007, the Ontario Court of Appeal called his incarceration and the subsequent 40 years of being labelled as Ms. Harper's killer "a miscarriage of justice." He was to receive $6.5-million in compensation.
DAVID MILGAARD
Found guilty of the 1969 murder of Gail Miller. Spent 23 years in prison. Received $10-million in compensation, including $750,000 payment to his mother.
THOMAS SOPHONOW
Found guilty of the murder of a 16-year-old Winnipeg waitress. Spent four years in jail before being freed in 1985. Received $2.5-million in compensation.
DONALD MARSHALL JR.
Found guilty of the 1971 murder of acquaintance Sandy Seale, who was actually killed in a robbery attempt. Spent 11 years in prison before being acquitted. Received a lifetime pension of $1.5-million.
CLAYTON JOHNSON
Found guilty in 1993 of murdering his wife when she had actually fallen down the stairs. Spent five years in prison before the conviction was overturned. Received $2.5-million.
RANDY DRUKEN
Found guilty of murdering his girlfriend in 1993. Spent nearly six years in prison before a jailhouse informant recanted his testimony. DNA evidence later implicated his brother. Received $2.1-million.
GUY PAUL MORIN
Tried for the 1984 murder of nine-year-old neighbour. Released in 1986, retried in 1992. Finally cleared in 1995 based on DNA evidence. Received $1.2-million in compensation.
JASON DIX
Convicted of murder in 1994 deaths of two Edmonton-area factory workers. Spent 22 months in jail before charges dismissed, based on case mismanagement by RCMP. Awarded nearly $765,000 damages.
RONALD DALTON
Charged with strangling his wife in 1988 and spent almost nine years in a Newfoundland jail. A retrial in 2000 found him not guilty. Paid $750,000 in compensation.
MOST RECENTLY, THE CASE OF IVAN HENRY
Ivan Henry already had a criminal history in 1983, a previous conviction for attempted rape. He also had a history of drug and alcohol abuse. According to a court-appointed psychiatrist, he was psychotic and suffered paranoid delusions.
Clearly, there was no advantage for him to defend himself on multiple sex charges in B. C. Supreme Court. But he did and despite a lack of reliable evidence -- and a host of other troublesome factors, unacknowledged at his trial but surfacing now -- Henry was convicted by a jury on three counts of rape, two counts of attempted rape and five of indecent assault.
A judge declared him a dangerous offender, which meant he might never experience freedom again.
He has spent the past 26 years in prison for crimes he has always maintained he did not commit.
Now released on bail, pending a decision on whether or not he will be re-tried, Ivan Henry has to learn how to live in a much changed world. Based on previous settlements for overturned convictions, he could easily be a recipient of several millions of dollars to smooth the way.
Would it not be more cost effective to monitor convictions with issues able to be reviewed by a totally separate group such as the Criminal Case Review Commission in England, one which is independent of police and prosecution, and on that will not cost the wrongfully convicted person hundreds of thousnds of dollars in lawyer fees?
Saturday, May 9, 2009
American injustice.
When I was younger, I listened a lot to Johnny Cash. I loved his gravely voice. Often times the songs he wrote and sang were sad. This was one I liked.
But that was before my son went to prison for a crime he did not commit. Now it is harder to listen to because of the life my son has had for the past 17 years. He was arrested at the young age of 17, and has been inside the prison since he was 19. He has been in Solitary confinement, and in general population. He has witnessed things that no one should ever have to see. Murders, drug overdoses, stabbings, suicides, and the list goes on.
He has been in a dark place for a very long time. Talk about missing someone, he has missed the birth of his neice; his girlfriend could not take the prison, so she stopped visiting. Now he is so far from home, it is difficult for me to visit.
A very dear friend sent me a link to a website that brought out a strong sense of Deja Vue.
Please help this man to clear himself and put the justice system right. He is a non violent man with no past criminal record who has been wrongfully convicted by the federal justice system. He was convicted solely on circumstantial evidence and nothing was proven during trial. The judge made this statement herself during sentencing.
There is, however, evidence to show that another person closely involved with Daniel (defendant) was responsible. The case was not properly investigated. Besides that - important evidence was destroyed at the police station before the FBI ever became involved. This evidence could have cleared Daniel of all charges had it not been destroyed forever by the police department.
All we ask is for a new trial and new investigation into this case. Why keep someone in prison for a crime they did not commit and allow the guilty party to walk free? Please help us! Even if Daniel were pardoned or his sentence commuted, he still plans on proving his innocence. It is a matter of principle. If you would like more information about this case please email me at blacksgeneralstore@gmail.com
I am Daniel's outside contact. If you want to help and need more details I would be happy to speak with you after initial email contact.
Thank for reading this.
Jonathan
Unless he gets the chance to prove his innocence, the rest of his life is ruined and for a crime he did not commit.
The similarities to my son's case are astounding.
http://criminaljustice.change.org/actions/view/help_for_a_wrongfully_convicted_man
http://www.canadianinjustice.com
compare them.
If you feel compelled to help, please write letters to the Prime Minister of Canada, at Parliament Buildings, 80 Wellington Street, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, K1A 0A2
Also visit the young man's site in the USA and add your signature to his petition.
Thursday, April 23, 2009
Conversation
Our neighbours and many other countries settled the same way treated Aboriginals like they were the interlopers. Aboriginals were pushed out of the way for immigrants to take the land and resources. Maybe not right away, but as soon as the European settlers became numerous enough to survive without help, they did so.
Canada's early settlers would not have survived their first winter without the help of the Aboriginal peoples in the area. That they did survive is a testiment to them, and a testiment to the Aboriginal peoples who taught them what was safe to eat, how to make a shelter from the cold, and so much more. Canada began right off the hop with a dialogue, a conversation with the native peoples.
Unfortunately, that dialogue no longer is helping the survival of Canada. My son, Derik Lord, is Metis. One of the aboriginal peoples of Canada. Since he has been in prison for a wrongful conviction, I have learned many things about the ongoing conversations in Canada.
I have discovered that there is a very large discrepancy between the percentage of European descent prisoners and Aboriginal ones. White prisoners get out of prison faster, get programs to help them faster, and are generally better treated than aboriginals. Aboriginal prisoners are kept in prisons longer, denied parole much more often, treated like scum and not given programs that will help them.
The Correctional Investigator for the Correctional Service of Canada has been pointing these facts out to the government and to the citizens of Canada for more than 20 years. So what has changed?
The Correctionsl Service of Canada now says they have special programs for Aboriginal prisoners. Just try to get into one of them! Derik has tried many times and always gets turned down as not needing the programs. He finally gave up.
He was convicted with another young man at the same trial and they both received the same sentence. Life - 10 means a life sentence with parole eligibility after 10 years. The other young man, white, got out at his 10 year eligibility. One parole hearing is all it took. Derik, Aboriginal, has now been in for 17 years, with 5 separate parole hearings all turning him down for release. Is this system fair? I think not.
It is good to talk about the conversations between the various poeples who made Canada what it is today, but where are the conversations when it comes to punishment?
The Correctional Service of Canada has a mandate to get its prisoners back out of prison, to resume a normal life outside the bars without criminal activity. It is supposed to be concerned with correcting, not punishing. After this long time, it is no longer in a correcting mindset, it is in a punishment mode. Derik has maintained his innocence all these years. The fact that he has not confessed should not be used to keep him in prison forever, but it is happening. He has been told, orally and in writing, and I have been told, orally and in writing, that if he would just confess, he would get parole. They make it sound like it would be that easy. It is not.
I don't believe that one bit. If he suddenly changed and said he did it, then they would just a quickly put him in line for all those programs designed to correct his behaviour. I feel very strongly that those programs would make it worse for him, not better. He will not learn what he should not do, but what he should have done. He already knows what he should not do and one of those things is he should not lie.
I am very proud of the man my son has become despite the events that have brought him to this day. He is a caring man. He volunteered for many years as a peer counsellor for other prisoners, helping them in many ways. I know he has saved marriages, prevented suicides, prevented murders and helped some kick their drug habits. His strength shows in the fact that he did not get involved with the drugs which are rampant within Canada's prisons.
Where is the conversation that will get him released? No one on his case management team will speak to me now.
Coach Elouise
604-794-3218
Skype elouise.lord
Email: lordelouise@gmail.com
rascal60@shaw.ca
http://www.canadianinjustice.com for more of the story.
Wednesday, April 15, 2009
Sunshine on my shoulders
A long time favorite song. I used to sing along to it when my family was whole. I remember so well the day that Derik was arrested. I had been trying to keep him calm for a few weeks by telling him things like: "You were not there, they can't arrest you without some evidence. Don't worry!"
In retrospect, that was a very bad idea.
The two women were murdered on the Thanksgiving long weekend, October 5, 1990. There was a lot of press and media attention because of the size of the estate, over $3 million dollars. Since the husband of the younger victim was a close personal friend of the then Lieutenant Governor of BC, David Lam, there was considerable political pressure on the Delta Police to solve it fast and to leave Ralph Huenemann alone.
http://www.canadianinjustice.com/
I remember the day we learned about the events of October 5/6, 1990. On Sunday, October 7, 1990, Derik was getting ready for work at the local Kmart when a friend of his from school called him with a very strange request. Jack wanted to know if we had a subscription to the Times Colonist newspaper. We did not. Jack then explained that he had received a wierd call from Darren Huenemann telling him that he would not be at school on Tuesday, and that his family had made the front page.
Derik and Darren had known each other at school for a year or so, and had visited occasionally at each other's homes. I knew Darren somewhat. A very nice, usually well dressed young man, always polite to adults, crazy sense of humour. The boys shared an interest in games and music, so they would hang around together at school, sometimes.
My husband went down to the local 7/11 to get a copy of the paper. There it was on the front page. Two gastly murders. Derik was very upset. He told me that Darren must be devastated because he and his mom had a relationship like ours. She wanted to know where he was going, and kept an eye on his activities. He described the relationship between Darren and his mother as close, like ours. Then he cried.
Darren was not available when Derik called him to express his feelings, because he was in Tsawwassen with his step-father, Ralph.
I had met Darren's mother, Sharon, we got along well, but had only met a couple of times. I had never met his grandmother, Doris Leatherbarrow, although Darren had spoken often about her. Seems she had his life and education planned out for him.
All moot now of course! They seemed to be close, too, from what Darren said.
We wondered how it had all come about, but just wanted to try and help Darren if we could. The next couple of months were pretty awful!
This was the beginning of the rest of our lives, never to be the same again.
Checkout the website for more details, and I will be back!
Tuesday, December 2, 2008
Words from Inside Canada's Prisons
Dignity’s Child
The Canadian Charter of Right’s and Freedoms
This submission was prepared by a Canadian prisoner for the “Roadmap to Strengthening Public Safety” conference held in Matsqui Institution on November 29th, 2008. The conference was presided over by Professor Michael Jackson, Q.C., of the UBC Faculty of Law, and Mr. Graham Stewart, former National Chairman for the John Howard Society of Canada. It was convened with support from the British Columbia Law Foundation for the purpose of formulating a response to the “Report of the Correctional Service of Canada Review Panel” of October 31st, 2007. The author of this submission chose anonymity so that his identity would in no way distract the reader from the truth of his message.
In the spring of 1982 I was 15 years old, living in a small city in B.C. Like many teenagers, I was preoccupied with motorcycles, girls, rock music, and dressing to impress my peers. Mostly I was unaware of something happening that spring that would have considerable influence on my future life. On April 17th Queen Elizabeth II and the Prime Minister of Canada signed a document that included the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, or “The Charter”. Though it meant little to me at the time, the Charter is a Canadian legal document that would have a greater effect on my life than any other.
Two short years later, I would enter British Columbia’s infamous Oakalla prison. From then until today, I am ashamed to concede that I have spent over 22 years inside of prisons just like this one (Matsqui). In that time, I have learned more about human indignity than many would think possible for an educated person living in one of the most “civilized” nations on earth.
Though I could not know it at the time, my entrance into Oakalla began a long search for human dignity. My dictionary defines dignity as, ‘the quality or state of being worthy, honored, or esteemed.’ By that definition, human dignity involves the way I view myself, the way others deal with me, and the way I view and treat others. While it is true that many things can affect the way I feel about myself, it is equally true that the way others treat me plays a large role in my everyday sense of personal value. I have been thinking a lot about that lately. Especially have I been thinking about it in light of the Charter. More than any other Canadian legal document, the Charter gives voice not only to how Canadians must treat each other, but more importantly, how we should view, or feel about each other.
For example, section 7 of the Charter states that “EVERYONE has the right to life, liberty and security of the person and the right not to be deprived thereof except in accordance with the principles of fundamental justice.”The right to life. The right to liberty. The right to security of their person. What the Charter is really stating is that humans have the right to DIGNITY, and the right to not be deprived of that dignity except in accordance with the principles of justice. These rights are not earned. The Charter did not give Canadians these rights. Dignity is my birthright as a human being. As I understand it, that is why these rights are referred to as fundamental HUMAN rights. They were not ceded to me, nor can they be withdrawn by human legislation. The Charter is merely Canada’s effort to validate my humanity and remind me of the responsibility I have to conduct myself with dignity by according dignity to everyone.
This reality is confirmed in section 15. (1), which states that “Every individual is equal before and under the law and has the right to the equal protection and equal benefit of the law without discrimination and, in particular, without discrimination based on race, national or ethnic origin, color, religion, sex, age or mental or physical disability. And again in section 2: EVERYONE has the following fundamental freedoms: a) conscience and religion; b) thought, belief, opinion and expression, including freedom of the press and other media of communication; c) peaceful assembly; and d) association. The right to be treated as equal in value to all other humans. The freedom to think what I want, feel what I want, worship how I choose, and associate with whomever I wish, wherever I want, as long it is peaceful. Again, did the Charter give me and the rest of Canadians these rights and freedoms? Never!
The Charter’s opening preamble states “Whereas Canada is founded upon principles that recognize the supremacy of God and the rule of law”. (Emphasis Mine) With these words, the Charter confirms that freedom, dignity, and right to be human comes from the highest authority – God – and these gifts are not to be removed from any person inside the borders of Canada “except in accordance with the principles of fundamental justice.” For greater certainty, the Charter confirms that any “principles of fundamental justice” must be “demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society”. In plain English, the Charter validates that the human right to dignity is God given, and inside the borders of Canada, no one dare assault the dignity of another human being without an extremely good reason. It further states that because Canada is a democracy, that “reason” is open to public discussion, debate, and even disapproval.
Sadly, while the Charter is an admirable attempt to enshrine dignity for every Canadian, it is condemned to failure. If my study of human laws has taught me anything, it is that from the Code of Hammurabi to the over-promoted U.S. Constitution, no written code has yet been devised that can govern what a man is on the inside. The significance of this becomes obvious when I admit that what I am on the inside ultimately determines the value I place on the dignity of myself and others.An outstanding example of this comes from the most famous code of human dignity ever devised. The historical giant Jesus Christ once stated, “All things, therefore, that you want men to do to you, you also must likewise do to them.” Referred to as the ‘Golden Rule’, it is in reality the ‘Golden Rule of human dignity’. Yet, as well known and accepted as this rule is, history tells a tragic tale of its mis- or non-application. Repeatedly, this Golden Rule of human relationships has been corrupted into the Golden Rule of retaliation; “All things, therefore, that men to do to you, you also must likewise do to them.” This “Golden Rule” has served as the principal rallying cry behind two world wars, countless religious pogroms and crusades, and an unending succession of so called “civil” wars. Moreover, once enacted, mankind has yet to find a way to stop this devalued version of the rule from degenerating into “Do to others worse than they have done to you”. This was Hitler’s ‘Golden Rule’ for annihilation of the Jews. It is a central pillar in the architecture of religious terrorism - from Munich in ‘72 to Northern Ireland in the 80’s to the World Trade Towers tragedy of 2001. It is the key element of U.S. foreign policy in Iraq, and has been the prevailing philosophy of various Middle Eastern factions since 1000 years before Christ. Now this dangerous and debased idea has reared its ugly head in the form of a “policy recommendation” made to and accepted by arguably the most powerful law enforcement agency in Canada. I am speaking of the CSC (Correctional Service of Canada).
Inside Canada’s territorial boundaries, no government agency has as much ability, or authority to “reasonably limit the rights and freedoms” of Canadian citizens as does this one. It is therefore a frightening spectre that inside this powerful, influential organization, the idea of “doing worse to others than they have done to you” has gained significant momentum. Most recently, it reveals itself in the form of the following recommendation made in the 2007 Correctional Service of Canada Review Panel Report:2. “The Panel recommends that the following amendments be made to section 4 of the CCRA:Note that the underlined text identifies the Panel’s recommended changes.…e) That offenders retain the basic [below minimum-standard] rights and privileges of all members of society, except those rights and privileges that are necessarily removed or restricted as a consequence of the sentence, [or] are required in order to encourage the offender to begin to and continue to engage in his or her correctional plan.3. The panel recommends that, at each security level (minimum, medium and Maximum), a basic level of rights should be defined. - “Roadmap to Strengthening Public Safety” at 216, 217. In layman’s terms, this recommendation promotes the idea that human rights can somehow be attenuated simply because a citizen resides in the penitentiary or because he has not shown ‘sufficient progress’ (a perilously subjective standard) in developing cognitive thinking skills. This recommendation represents the most dangerous philosophy in Canadian society today. In Canada, our definition of the basic rights that a human has from the time of birth are those written in the Charter. To suggest otherwise - as the Roadmap report does - is not only absurd, it is irresponsibly dangerous. This is this ideology that fostered horrid and tragic human rights abuses in Canada’s Indian reservations and residential schools for over a century. It is the same doctrine that led to the conditions of segregation in the British Columbia Penitentiary in 1975, when it was shamefully declared by a Canadian court to be a form of cruel and unusual punishment. When will we learn that to devalue the rights of any human is to devalue the human himself?
In the 20th century, the dehumanization of certain ‘categorized’ citizens led numerous countries to commit state-sponsored atrocities in such proportions as to never be erased from our collective consciousness. Stalinist purges, Cambodian killing fields, ‘Cultural Revolution’ in Maoist China, and the Holocaust all have in common that they were carried out by the state against their own citizenry. While many are left wondering how responsible, civilized governments could ever conduct themselves with such brutality against their own citizenry, there is a lesson to be learned in reviewing the laws and policies of those countries during those times. Without exception, justification for the state’s monstrous conduct can be found in legal decrees defining ‘certain groups of citizens’ as unworthy of the full compliment of human rights. Alarmingly, this is the slippery slope that the “Roadmap to Strengthening Public Safety” advocates. That alarm should sound loud and clear in the heart of any who would learn from history.
Evidently though, it is not. What is of great alarm - to those of us under the authority of the Correctional Service of Canada – is that this report and its recommendations have been both accepted and approved of by the ruling political party and the Commissioner of the CSC. As CSC began its 2008 implementation of the “transition” doctrine outlined in the “Roadmap” report, the opposition political parties have not uttered a word of disagreement or criticism. Even inside of CSC, where there exist judicious, experienced officials who have spent long careers ever vigilant for the types of human rights abuses indigenous to a penitentiary environment, there has been an awkward and conspicuous silence in the critique of a document widely perceived as representing the most regressive Correctional philosophy since the Canadian Penitentiary Act of 1868.
The reason for this noticeable hush is difficult to pinpoint. However, my commentary on the rapid and unimpeded rise of reactionary correctional philosophy as presented in the “Roadmap” report would be incomplete if I did not mention – even in brief - the equally rapid and unprecedented increase in influence of what has become a defacto “shadow administration” inside CSC – the Union of Canadian Correctional Officers (UCCO).UCCO’s roots can be traced to the late 1980’s and early 90’s. During that time, the CSC underwent a major organisational restructuring spearheaded by an aspirational Mission Statement, a new model for institutional management and a research-based cognitive model for prison programs. Front-line security officers soon found their authority and role in a reorganized, mission-driven CSC reduced in favor of cognitive-therapy treatment. An organization that had for 150 years supplied lifetime employment to consecutive generations of high school educated men was perceived by those same men as having turned its back on them – in favor of a correctional model that ceded greater dignity to the criminal offender. Many of these officers felt that the greater human rights – or dignity – being expended to prisoners was coming at the expense of their own dignity. (See “Toward a Policy for Canada’s Penitentiaries – The Evolution of Canada’s Prison System and the Transformation of the Correctional Officer’s Role (1950-2002)” http://www.ucco-sacc.csn.qc.cp/pregenerate/cmsFrameMain_EN_national_V05072Z0628670845PM.html?Lang=EN&ParentID=national&SectionID=V05072Z0628670845) This perception was undoubtedly strengthened by CSC budgetary decisions that oversaw a reallocation of financial resources from front line security into correctional programs and reintegration initiatives. Bitter, unfruitful contract negotiations between CSC and the Union representing Federal Public Servants (PSAC) in the early 1990’s provided fertile ground for a upsurge of resentment amongst front line Correctional Officers. The match that lit the tinder finally came in 1997, when CSC exponentially increased its fiscal budget for correctional programs facilitated by Sociology graduates, while simultaneously reducing its budget for front line Correctional Officers. CSC’s message was clear. In the field of corrections, the 21st century would belong to Canada, with its pioneering model of therapeutic, cognitive-training based correctional ‘healing’ environments. “Citizen lawbreakers” would be accorded personal dignity with an expectancy that they would follow suit by according dignity to others. It was a correctional philosophy that the front line Correctional Officers would never buy into. To the contrary, they became this philosophy’s most successful opponents.Exploring the success behind UCCO’s meteoric rise of influence inside the criminal justice system would make for a fascinating book, and is certainly beyond the reach of this submission. However, it is an important observation that now, in late 2008, no single entity inside of Canada’s criminal justice system holds greater influence over current and future correctional policy than does the Union of Canadian Correctional Officers. At the penitentiary level, prison Administrators cringe in apprehension when facing even potential conflict with UCCO representatives. At the national level, Correctional Officials at the highest levels of CSC are perceived by many middle managers to be “in the pocket” of UCCO. Anecdotal evidence even exists that UCCO is on the primary distribution list of the current government’s cabinet briefs concerning Corrections – ahead of even CSC Commissioners! Perhaps most revealing in terms of UCCO’s sphere of influence, is that a great many of the recommendations made by the “Independent CSC Review Panel” in their “Roadmap” report to the government are ‘cut-and-paste’ out of widely available UCCO promotional literature detailing the union’s future vision of Corrections in Canada. (Compare “Toward a Policy for Canada’s Penitentiaries – The Evolution of Canada’s Prison System and the Transformation of the Correctional Officer’s Role (1950-2002)” at page 131) This reality presents an obvious problem. While the primary mandate of the Corrections and Conditional Release Act is Public Safety, the Trade Union known as UCCO is focused primarily on the financial and career advantages of its due paying members. On a great many levels, these two agendas are mutually exclusive. Of equal importance to UCCO is an increase in due-paying members, thus greater enabling it to fulfill its primary mandate. On their face, correctional policies that grant greater dignity for criminal offenders, with emphasis on reintegration and lower rates of recidivism are by their very nature antithetical to UCCO’s primary goal – securing long lasting employment and influence for Correctional Officers. Logically then UCCO leadership does, and MUST oppose both legislation and policy that promotes human rights for criminal offenders. UCCO does not hide this organizational philosophy, rather freely advocating it in the promotional literature found at its website (http://www.ucco-sacc.csn.qc.cp) While couching its opposition to human rights (dignity) for criminal offenders in language supportive of staff safety and dignity, UCCO’s resistance is in reality a rejection of the social healing model of corrections in favor of a punitive, control and domination model requiring an ever larger legion of front line Correctional Officers.
This rejection of CSC’s mission-driven model, combined with the great political influence UCCO currently wields, is the evident reason that innovative CSC sites such as the Kwìkwèxwelhp Healing Village in B.C. have – as of November 2008 - a 17% occupancy rate while Medium Security facilities that tend towards keeping offenders incarcerated for longer periods under greater control are full to the point of double bunking. UCCO’s strategy in this regard has been little short of brilliant, transforming itself in 10 short years from a grass-roots movement of marginal, disgruntled public service employees into a powerful lobbying machine capable of dictating terms to its employer and essentially guaranteeing life-long career employment for its membership. Lamentably, for CSC and the tax-paying public they represent, it is not at all evident that UCCO’s strategy strengthens public safety in any way. The Union’s very public promotion of a return to a pre-Charter style penitentiary environment is in actuality a vote of support for the ultra-violent prison conditions of the 1970’s that led to riots, hostage takings, and murders in penitentiaries across Canada, as documented in the following words of the MacGuigan report of 1977:Seven years of comparative peace in the Canadian penitentiary system ended in 1970 with a series of upheavals (riots, strikes, murders and hostage-takings) that grew in numbers and size with each passing year. By 1976 the prison explosions were almost constant; hardly a week passed without another violent incident. The majority were in Canada's maximum security institutions. In the 42 years between 1932 and 1974, there was a total of 65 major incidents in federal penitentiaries. Yet in two years – 1975 and 1976 – there was a total of 69 major incidents, including 35 hostage-takings involving 92 victims, one of whom (a prison officer) was killed. (House of Commons Sub-Committee on the Penitentiary System in Canada, Report to Parliament [Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services, 1977] [Chairman: Mark MacGuigan] at 5) I have spoken with a number of institutional level correctional managers who feel that with the adoption of the ‘transformation agenda’ outlined in the “Roadmap” report, this 20 year tug of war between two competing ideologies inside of CSC has now been decided in favor of UCCO and its Allies. If this is so, there is great fear amongst many stakeholders that CSC is on the cusp of the largest regression of human rights since the patriation of the Canadian Constitution. It would be unrealistically biased of me to be so critical of the “Roadmap” report and not present an alternative. Yet, I freely admit that any alternative I could present would only be one more theory in a long line of theories presented by those seeking a utopian society. The truth is, crime is ugly. In every form, it is an assault on the human dignity of another. I know of which I speak.
In 1983, I began my all out assault on dignity. It began with a breach of financial trust, and ended 12 years later with the ultimate indignity - when I deprived another human being of his right to life. Yet, as implausible as it may sound, I now know that during that time I was desperately seeking “worth, honor, and esteem.” You will recall that this is how the dictionary defined “dignity”. How did a person searching so desperately for dignity become so undignified?I have thought about that question for many years now. The conclusion I’ve reached is that even though we are born with dignity, the world we are born into is full of indignity. My power of reason leads me to believe that powerful unseen wicked forces beyond our control are influencing the entire human family. How else can we explain the global epidemic of sexual slavery, child molestation, family violence, drug addiction and alcoholism, war, violent crime, starvation and poverty, environmental destruction and gross economic injustice? We may be born innocent, but it doesn’t remain that way for long. If dignity is a human birthright, then the world we are born into is a thief relentlessly seeking to steal it away. Unfortunately, this is the model we learn from the youngest age. When dignity is first taken from us, we feel “indignant”. Without correction, our base response is to take dignity from others in an attempt to retrieve our own. Logically, this “tit-for-tat” model of conflict resolution is the wrong response. It only creates a firestorm of people robbing dignity from others. Yet it is the model we continue to follow into adulthood – often without second thought. What it creates is a life cycle of indignity as the pendulum swings between losing and taking dignity.
Lawmakers know this well. In April of 1945, in an endorsement of the Charter of the newly formed United Nations Organization, U.S. President Harry Truman publicly stated: “We must build a new world—a far better world—one in which the eternal dignity of man is respected.” (Emphasis Mine) It is this attempt to validate “eternal dignity” for all that drives lawmakers to draft codes such as the Charter. It was with similar intent that in 1986, Canadian lawmakers set out to create “new correctional legislation which gives guidance to correctional staff and promotes fair and effective decision-making; it should facilitate operations and be clear and unambiguous; it should be internally consistent; it should promote the dignity and fair treatment of inmates; and reflect the interests of staff, offenders, and of all others affected by the correctional system.” (Emphasis Mine) (A Framework For the Correctional Law Review - Correctional Law Review Working Paper No. 2, - June 1986) Why should such legislation “promote the dignity and fair treatment of inmates”? The answer to that question strikes at the root of how Canadian citizens end up in prison.
As stated earlier, I am in prison because of committing one of the greatest indignities known to man. I forcibly took away another person’s dignity. His right to “worth, honor, and esteem”. His right to life. In doing so, I likewise gave up my own human dignity. Notice, I did not say I gave up my right to dignity. A human’s right to dignity can only be removed by the one who created him. Rather, in my case, I threw away my own dignity. At that time, Canadian society was forced to decide how to respond. Was revenge the right model? By killing me, they could enact upon me the same indignity I had enacted on my victim. Though I wouldn’t learn anything from the experience, perhaps it would teach the rest of society that taking away the dignity of another would be met with a forcible and severe removal of their dignity. Or, perhaps, as is the case in some societies, it would be better to publicly torture and maim me. That way revenge could be satisfied as my dignity is taken away on a repeated and daily basis.
In the end, Canadian society chose the moral high road. Perhaps this course was chosen on the perception that a person born into a world with so much indignity is not solely responsible for treating others with indignity. So, it was decided that in my case – and the cases of thousands of other Canadian citizens – Canadian society would attempt to teach us how to treat others with dignity. But how could this best be accomplished on such a large scale? In 1986, it was decided to create a new body of law that would – amongst other things – “promote the dignity and fair treatment of inmates”. This new body of law would take 6 years to create, span the mandate of two separate governments, and involve the labours of hundreds of lawmakers, social workers, International partners, university professors, CSC staff, lawyers, and community liaisons. The working papers alone for this project cover 2 years and 481 pages of summary reports. I know, I’ve read all of them. The final result was the CCRA – The Corrections and Conditional Release Act and the accompanying Regulations. In the opening sections of the CCRA, this law boldly stated its goal:Purpose of correctional system3. The purpose of the federal correctional system is to contribute to the maintenance of a just, peaceful and safe society by(a) carrying out sentences imposed by courts through the safe and humane custody and supervision of offenders; and(b) assisting the rehabilitation of offenders and their reintegration into the community as law-abiding citizens through the provision of programs in penitentiaries and in the community. (Emphasis Mine)A “just, peaceful and safe society”. “Rehabilitation”. “Law abiding citizens.” Perhaps these principles are best summed up in the CCRA sections 70, which states:Living conditions, etc.70. The Service shall take all reasonable steps to ensure that penitentiaries, the penitentiary environment, the living and working conditions of inmates and the working conditions of staff members are safe, healthful and free of practices that undermine a person’s sense of personal dignity. (Emphasis Mine)The rationale behind this legislation is easily understood. Stripping a person of dignity is often more brutal than inflicting physical blows. It is devastating to the human spirit. A devastated, dehumanized human spirit is a dangerous thing. When humans become dehumanized, they tend to act inhumanely. This was the lesson learned painfully through the events in B.C. Pen, Millhaven, Archambault, and Kingston Penitentiary in the 1970’s and early 80’s. Some in the CSC today choose to irresponsibly forget that those lessons were paid for with the blood of both prisoners and Correctional Officers. A more pleasant lesson CSC has both learned and preached since that time is that when accorded greater dignity, human inclination is to conduct oneself, and treat others more humanely. In the 20 years since the creation of CSC’s Mission and the subsequent inception of the CCRA, incidents of prison violence in general, violent recidivism by parolees, and violent crime committed by successful beneficiaries of CSC correctional programming have reduced dramatically. Of equal interest is the anecdotal evidence that exceptions to these downward trends in violence exist most strongly at penitentiary sites where UCCO opposition to the therapeutic healing environment proceeds unchecked. Inversely, incidents of prison violence (against staff and offenders), criminal misconduct, and recidivism are lowest at sites designed to promote human dignity and social healing. Foremost amongst these sites are the minimum-security institutions and native healing villages. Yet, it spite of some evidence supporting the CCRA’s efficacy in validating dignity in criminal offenders, it too - like its parent the Charter - is doomed to failure. Mankind’s history with the ‘rule of law’ shows clearly that no written code, be it the CCRA in its current form nor a version modified according to the “Roadmap” recommendations, can govern the human heart. Our model of cognition states that thoughts lead to feelings, and feelings lead to actions. The rule of law cannot govern the feelings that lead to human indignity. Only when the “rule of law” gives way to the ‘rule of love’ will we in retrospect realize how ridiculous our attempts to “codify” human dignity were.
Only when humanity writes the Golden Rule on its heart instead of paper will our starvation for dignity finally be satisfied. I, for one am FULL OF HOPE that I will see that realized in my lifetime. But it will not come about through “the rule of law”, as the Charter’s opening words allude. Rather, my confidence lies in the other statement made in the Charter’s preamble – that through the “Supremacy of God”, all citizens will attain to dignity. While we await that Supremacy, I strongly encourage anyone hearing or reading these words to reject fear, reject dehumanization, reject those who would sacrifice the safety of Canadian citizens in exchange for narrow political and financial agendas, and instead embrace HUMAN DIGNITY. When we dignify others – even more so than we feel they deserve - we in truth dignify ourselves. In dignifying ourselves, we dignify ALL humanity. This is the vision that Canadians must welcome and promote – even for those guilty of our society’s greatest indignities.
Coach Elouise
604-794-3218
Skype elouise.lord
Email: rascal60@shaw.ca
http://tinyurl.com/6jhsm5
Sunday, August 31, 2008
And the beat goes on...
His passes for which he received appoval last February are not progressing at all. He has had 1 pass in 6 months. He goes to check on Mondays and Fridays to see if he is going to the meetings (L.I.N.C.), but it has become just another joke. The staff just laugh when they see him coming.
Way to go guys!
Nice rehabilitation going on here!
Monday, August 4, 2008
How do you get a loved one out of prison?
His IPO once again asked that he wthdraw his application for a transfer. When he asked why, she could only say William Head does not want him. So he asked what do I have to do next. Her reply was "I don't know" The usual.
He has not had an IPO who appears to understand the job or know what to do to get him on the way out of prison. That pat answer has been the one he has heard for at least 10 years now. I ask the same questions when I call, but I get the same pat answer.
There is nothing left on Derik's correctional plan. There are no further programs, no further education, no further work experience that can be had at Matsqui.
He is way past his parole date. He has been warehoused for nearly half his life. The only reason that I can see for him still being there is racism. He is Metis. He does not lie, he does not cheat, he does not shirk responsibility, he maintains his innocence, he stays in prison. It is beyond time that he was released.
He was granted escorted passes to go to LINC meetings. Last February. He has received only one pass since and gone out one time. Apparently no more are forthcoming. His IPO wants more passes before she does anything. He cannot get more passes without overtime for guards. That is not coming any time soon. It is time for Michelle to get off her butt and set something in motion for him. Do your job!
Elouise
http://www.canadianinjustice.com
http://coachelouise.com
Saturday, July 19, 2008
We still carry on and Derik is still behind bars.
What does it take to get out of jail in this country?
Apparently it takes a lot of money, lies, sex and videotapes.
If you have any ideas, please post.
Coach Elouise
Monday, November 26, 2007
Visiting Dilemma
Booking should be straight forward and simple, bu that is not always the case. sometimes, you might have to try 20 times or so to get through. Not that they are busy, but they do not always feel like answering the phone. Once that is done, you proceed to the visit itself.
Getting there is usually fine, but then the procedures to get in might just get your goat. Please do not forge to bring ID. You will not be able to sign in without that. Then hope that your clothes are very clean, with no residue of any kind on them. You will be requested to swipe a piece of filter paper on your clothing that will be tested for contact with many known drugs. This is geared to esure that drugs are not being brought in to the prison by you. Unfortunately, the ion scanner is only checking for certain ions, not recognizing compounds. That means that if you are a diabetic, heroin will show up on the scanner test. Or if you take a cold medication, just a simple over the counter one, you may be hitting with cocaine or amphetamines on the scanner. If you have been shopping, there may be traces of all kinds of things on your hands and clothing. Eventually, you will learn how to avoid these traps.
Then you go to the visiting room and wait some more. I have found that it usually takes about 20 minutes to get through all the front gate stuff and another 20 minutes to wait for the prisoner. the visits are set for 3 hours, but, as you can see, you do not usually get a 3 hour visit. Always a tense time, but the visit is worth the effort. At least when a mother can see her son, it eases her worries for at least a little while.